[Crm-sig] Disjunct properties

Dan Matei danmatei50 at gmail.com
Thu Jan 8 23:00:22 EET 2015


Hi everyone (and Happy New Year !)


I ask again for advice... How to express (elegantly) a disjunction between
two properties ?


Context:


Case 1:

In less than two weeks I came across two paintings (one in Bucharest and
one in Baltimore) having alternative authorship (not in the sense of
"controversial" attribution).


The Baltimore one is:
http://art.thewalters.org/detail/29205/massacre-of-the-innocents/


The label on the Walters Museum wall reads:


Bartolo di Fredi or Andrea di Bartolo (son)


The description ("...The Massacre of the Innocents might have been executed
by both Bartolo and Andrea (active 1389-1428), working collaboratively as a
father and son team....") indicates that we have here an inclusive OR.


Note: an art historian tells me that there are a lot of such cases !


Case 2:


An alternative dating, e.g.


Tiziano VECELLIO, dit TITIEN (Pieve di Cadore, 1488/1490 - Venise, 1576)



For the moment, I have only a "brute force" solution (sorry for the lack of
rigour):


Case 1:


<id0> <[E22] The Massacre of the Innocents> < crm:P108i_was_produced_by>
<[E12] id-creation>


<id1> <[E12] id-creation> <crm:P11_had_participant> <[E21] Bartolo>


<id2> <[E12] id-creation> <crm:P11_had_participant> <[E21] Andrea di
Bartolo>


<id3> <id1> <inclusiveOr> <id2>


NB. I could handle the controversial attributions in a similar way. Since
each of my statements is linked to its provenance, i.e. to a
crm:E13_Attribute Assignment, each alternative attribution is linked to a
different E13.



Case 2:


<id4> <[E21] Tiziano> <crm:P98i was_born> <[E67] id-birth>


<id5> <[E67] id-birth> <crm:P4_has_time-span> <[E52] 1488>


<id6> <[E67] id-birth> <crm:P4_has_time-span> <[E52] 1490>


<id7> <id5> <exclusiveOr> <id6>



It is possible to avoid <inclusiveOr> and <exclusiveOr> ? (I'm not too
happy with this solution.)


Thanks,


Dan
-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: <http://lists.ics.forth.gr/pipermail/crm-sig/attachments/20150108/01ae3cb8/attachment.html>


More information about the Crm-sig mailing list