[Crm-sig] Manifestation: title and statement of responsibility

[sfakakis at ionio.gr]

Dear Dan

While your case is a "classical" UNIMARC example of two works by two 
authors in the same manifestation (without a collective title), actually 
it is not one title with its accompanying statement of responsibility, 
as you suggested to represent, but two titles with their accompanying 
statements of responsibility.

Also, both properties P110 has Title and P148 has component are many to 
many. So, in order to preserve the above semantics we could represent 
the two titles, as well as the statements of responsibility, as distinct 
instances. The issue now is to associate each statement of 
responsibility to its accompanying title, where probably we could use 
the property P67 refers to (could we, is there a more dedicated 
property?).

Best regards,
Michalis

-----------------------------------------------------------------------
Dr. Michalis Sfakakis

Database and Information Systems Research Group (DBIS)
Laboratory on Digital Libraries and Electronic Publishing
Department of Archives, Library Science and Museology
Faculty of Information Science and Informatics
Ionian University

Ioannou Theotoki 72, GR49100 Corfu, Greece

email: sfakakis at ionio.gr
-----------------------------------------------------------------------



Στις 2014-12-15 00:52, Dan Matei έγραψε:
> Friends,
> 
> Struggling with my UNIMARC (and bibliographic references in museum
> records, for that matter) mapping to FRBRoo, I have an issue with the
> proposed mappings (page 106 in FRBRoo 2.0) of the title and statement
> of responsibility of a manifestation. That is:
> 
> Manifestation: Title of the manifestation
> 
> <F3 Manifestation Product Type> <P102 has title> <E35 Title>
> 
> Manifestation: Statement of responsibility
> 
> <F3 Manifestation Product Type> <CLR6 should carry> <F24 Publication
> Expression> <P148 has component> <E33 Linguistic Object> <P2 has type>
> <E55 Type {“Statement of responsibility”}>
> 
> In this scenario, how to map the "classical" UNIMARC example of two
> works by two authors in the same manifestation (without a collective
> title) ? i.e.
> 
> 200 l#$aPour les valeurs bourgeoises$fpar Georges Hourdin$cContre les
> valeurs bourgeoises$fpar Gilbert Ganne
> 
> See:
> 
> www.worldcat.org/title/pour-les-valeurs-bourgeoises-par-georges-hourdin-contre-les-valeurs-bourgeoises-par-gilbert-ganne/oclc/460654543
> [1]
> 
> http://catalogue.bnf.fr/servlet/biblio?ID=33045411 [2]
> 
> I would suggest for such edge cases to add a possibility:
> 
> Manifestation: Title and statement of responsibility
> 
> <F3 Manifestation Product Type> <CLR6 should carry> <F24 Publication
> Expression> <P148 has component> <E33 Linguistic Object> <P2 has type>
> <E55 Type {“Title and statement of responsibility”}>
> 
> Dan
> 
> PS. Dear Patrick, how come that the manifestation used as example in
> the UNIMARC manual is coded differently in the BnF catalogue ? See:
> 
> http://catalogue.bnf.fr/servlet/biblio?ID=33045411&SN1=0&SN2=0&idNoeud=1.1.1&FormatAffichage=4
> [3]
> 
> Exception culturelle ? :-)
> 
> 
> 
> Links:
> ------
> [1]
> http://www.worldcat.org/title/pour-les-valeurs-bourgeoises-par-georges-hourdin-contre-les-valeurs-bourgeoises-par-gilbert-ganne/oclc/460654543
> [2] http://catalogue.bnf.fr/servlet/biblio?ID=33045411
> [3]
> http://catalogue.bnf.fr/servlet/biblio?ID=33045411&SN1=0&SN2=0&idNoeud=1.1.1&FormatAffichage=4
> 
> _______________________________________________
> Crm-sig mailing list
> Crm-sig at ics.forth.gr
> http://lists.ics.forth.gr/mailman/listinfo/crm-sig