[Crm-sig] Improvement of E51 scope note

[Christian-Emil Ore]

There is difference in levels: E-mail addresses, telephone numbers, post 
office boxes, Fax numbers, etc". All but "post office boxes" refer to an 
  identifier. If consistent it should be "post office box number". I 
don't think it is necessary to explain the nater of a post office box in 
the scope note. That is very, very specific. Besides a post office box 
nubmer is usually a part of an adress as is the street number.

Regards,
Christian-Emil

On 08.11.2007 09:27, Stephen Stead wrote:
> I have tried a slight alteration to the opening sentence to make it sound a
> bit less "Geeky" and adjusted the PO Box note. In fact PO Boxes are
> associated with an instance of E53 Place which is the physical box or
> sorting office slot where the mail is placed prior to collection or
> forwarding (I had a PO box for many years when I lived on a boat!). In the
> opening sentence I think we could probably lose the "or understood" without
> any loss of meaning and while enhancing readability.
> 
>  New version:
> 
> E51 Contact Point
> 
> Subclass of:	E77 Persistent Item
> Superclass of:	E45 Address
> 
> Scope Note:	This class comprises identifiers employed or understood by 
> communication services to mediate the communication with specific 
> instances of E39 Actor.
> 
> These include E-mail addresses, telephone numbers, post office boxes, 
> Fax numbers, etc. Most postal addresses can be considered both as 
> instances of E44 Place Appellation and E51 Contact Point.  In such cases 
> the subclass E45 Address should be used. However, a post office box may 
> not be associated with a place specific to its number.
> 
> Examples:	
> 	+41 22 418 5571
> 	weasel at paveprime.com
> 
> New New version:
> 
> E51 Contact Point
> 
> Subclass of:	E77 Persistent Item
> Superclass of:	E45 Address
> 
> Scope Note:	This class comprises identifiers employed, or understood, by
> 
> communication services to direct communications to an instance of E39 Actor.
> 
> These include E-mail addresses, telephone numbers, post office boxes, 
> Fax numbers, etc. Most postal addresses can be considered both as 
> instances of E44 Place Appellation and E51 Contact Point.  In such cases 
> the subclass E45 Address should be used. However, a post office box may 
> not be associated with a place in the way normal addresses are.
> 
> Examples:	
> 	+41 22 418 5571
> 	weasel at paveprime.com
> 
> 
> Stephen Stead
> Tel +44 20 8668 3075 
> Mob +44 7802 755 013
> E-mail steads at paveprime.com
> 
> -----Original Message-----
> From: crm-sig-bounces at ics.forth.gr [mailto:crm-sig-bounces at ics.forth.gr] On
> Behalf Of martin
> Sent: 07 November 2007 09:58
> To: crm-sig
> Subject: [Crm-sig] Improvement of E51 scope note
> 
> Dear All,
> 
> Here my proposal to improve the scope note of E51:
> 
> current version:
> 
> E51 Contact Point
> 
> 
> Subcass of:	E77 Persistent Item
> Superclass of:	E45 Address
> 
> Scope Note:	This class comprises identifiers used to communicate with 
> instances of E39 Actor.
> 
> These include E-mail addresses, telephone numbers, post office boxes, 
> Fax numbers, etc. Most postal addresses can be considered both as 
> instances of E44 Place Appellation and E51 Contact Point. The E45 
> Address subclass should be used in such cases.
> 
> Examples:	
> 	+41 22 418 5571
> 	weasel at paveprime.com
> 
> 
> New version:
> 
> E51 Contact Point
> 
> Subcass of:	E77 Persistent Item
> Superclass of:	E45 Address
> 
> Scope Note:	This class comprises identifiers employed or understood by 
> communication services to mediate the communication with specific 
> instances of E39 Actor.
> 
> These include E-mail addresses, telephone numbers, post office boxes, 
> Fax numbers, etc. Most postal addresses can be considered both as 
> instances of E44 Place Appellation and E51 Contact Point.  In such cases 
> the subclass E45 Address should be used. However, a post office box may 
> not be associated with a place specific to its number.
> 
> Examples:	
> 	+41 22 418 5571
> 	weasel at paveprime.com
>